Fresh Dog Food Compared: Ollie vs PetPlate vs Nom Nom (2026)

Fresh dog food delivery promises human-grade ingredients, vet-formulated recipes, and portions matched to your dog. It costs several times more than kibble, so the question is whether the convenience and quality justify it. The Farmer's Dog, Ollie, PetPlate, and Nom Nom are the names that come up most. Here is how they compare.

One note before the details: switch foods gradually over a week or more, and clear any diet change with your vet first if your dog has health issues.

How fresh food delivery works

You fill out a quiz about your dog: breed, age, weight, activity level, allergies. The company builds a meal plan with daily portions, cooks the food fresh, and ships it frozen on a schedule. You thaw and serve. Prices are quoted per day and scale steeply with dog size. Feeding a Chihuahua costs a fraction of feeding a Labrador.

The Farmer's Dog: our top pick

The Farmer's Dog is the biggest name in fresh dog food for a reason: vet-formulated recipes cooked to human-grade standards, portions tuned to your dog's exact profile, and the most mature delivery operation in the category. The food arrives frozen in pre-portioned packs, so serving is as simple as thaw and pour.

The quiz covers breed, age, weight, activity, and health issues, and the resulting plan adjusts portions as your dog changes. Pricing scales with dog size like every fresh service: small dogs cost a fraction of large breeds per day. Trial discounts are common, so compare the ongoing price, not the first-box teaser.

The tradeoff is price. This is premium feeding, and for large dogs the monthly cost rivals a car payment. But for owners who want the most established fresh-food operation with the deepest recipe testing, it is the default recommendation. See plans at The Farmer's Dog.

Ollie

Ollie offers several protein recipes (beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb at time of writing), all formulated with veterinary nutritionists to meet AAFCO standards. The quiz customizes portions, and you can mix fresh food with their gently baked line to cut costs.

Pricing scales with dog size: small dogs on full fresh plans cost a few dollars a day, rising steeply for large breeds. Half-fresh plans, where you mix fresh food with kibble you buy separately, bring the daily cost down substantially.

Ollie's onboarding gets high marks. The starter box includes a feeding guide, a storage container, and a gradual transition plan. See plans at Ollie.

PetPlate

PetPlate's pitch is variety. It offers several vet-designed recipes across different proteins, and the company emphasizes that rotating proteins can help picky eaters stay interested. Meals are cooked fresh and portioned to your dog's profile.

Pricing sits in the same band as Ollie at time of writing: a few dollars a day for small dogs, climbing with size. PetPlate frequently runs introductory discounts on the first box, so compare the ongoing price, not the first-box teaser.

Where PetPlate stands out is the picky-eater angle. If your dog turns up its nose at the same food twice in a row, recipe rotation is a genuine advantage.

Nom Nom

Nom Nom leans hardest on the science. Recipes are formulated by veterinary nutritionists, and the company publishes more detail about its nutritional philosophy than most competitors. It also sells a standalone probiotic supplement, which fits the gut-health positioning.

The lineup is smaller, with fewer protein options than Ollie or PetPlate at time of writing. Pricing is comparable to the other two, with the same steep scaling by dog size.

Nom Nom's strength is trust through transparency. For owners who read ingredient panels and want the most vet-forward brand story, it resonates.

Head to head

Recipe variety: PetPlate, with the widest protein rotation. Ollie is close. Nom Nom is narrower.

Customization: Ollie and The Farmer's Dog. The quizzes, portion tuning, and half-fresh options give the most control over cost.

Transparency and vet credentials: Nom Nom edges ahead on published nutritional detail.

Price: All four land in a similar band, scaling steeply with dog size. Introductory discounts are common, so compare ongoing prices.

Transition support: All four include transition guides. Ollie's starter kit is the most polished.

Is fresh food actually healthier?

There is no large-scale study proving fresh delivery beats a high-quality kibble. What fresh food does offer is ingredient transparency, controlled portions, and palatability that gets picky dogs eating. Dogs with dull coats or digestive grumbles sometimes improve after a diet change, but that can be the novelty as much as the nutrition. Treat fresh food as a quality-of-life upgrade, not medicine.

Saving money on fresh plans

The half-fresh approach is the sweet spot for most budgets: replace half the daily calories with fresh food and keep a good kibble for the rest. Longer plans and introductory discounts also help. And measure honestly: an overweight dog fed premium food is still an overweight dog.

Verdict by dog type

Best for picky eaters: PetPlate. Recipe rotation keeps mealtime interesting.

Best for budget-conscious fresh feeding: Ollie. Half-fresh plans and baked-food mixing cut the daily cost without going back to plain kibble.

Best for owners who want maximum vet-forward transparency: Nom Nom.

Best for multi-dog homes: Price it per dog before committing. Fresh food for three large dogs can exceed $800 a month at time of writing, which is where half-fresh plans earn their keep.

Fresh food is a real upgrade over low-end kibble, but it is not magic. A high-quality kibble or a half-fresh plan beats a stretched budget every time. For treats and everyday kibble to mix in, Chewy carries most major brands at competitive prices.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.