A monthly box of toys and treats sounds like a luxury until you watch your dog lose interest in the same old toys. Subscription boxes fix that with fresh surprises on a schedule. The two biggest names, BarkBox and Super Chewer, both come from the same parent company, BARK. They target different dogs.

How they work

Both ship monthly. Both include toys, treats, and chews picked around a theme. Both offer free shipping and a satisfaction guarantee that replaces items your dog does not like. The differences are in toughness, contents, and price.

BarkBox

The original. Each box contains 2 toys, 2 treat bags, and 1 chew, built around a monthly theme. Past themes have included everything from fast food to fairy tales. At time of writing, plans start around $35 per month on a 12-month plan, with month-to-month costing more.

Customization is a strong point. You can set toy preferences, flag allergies, and size everything for your dog. There is also a toy-free option that doubles the treats, which suits dogs that destroy every plush in minutes.

The toys are cute and creative, but they are standard plush and rubber, not built for destruction. Power chewers will gut them fast.

Plans come in 1, 6, and 12-month lengths. The 12-month plan has the lowest monthly price. Month-to-month costs the most but lets you cancel anytime. You can pause or cancel from the account page without calling anyone.

Super Chewer

Super Chewer is BarkBox's tougher sibling, aimed at dogs who destroy ordinary toys. Each box has 2 tough toys, 2 treat bags, and 2 chews. The toys use stronger materials: reinforced plush, rubber, and nylon blends rated for aggressive chewing.

At time of writing, plans start around $45 per month on longer commitments. That is about $10 more than BarkBox, which buys the tougher toy lineup and an extra chew per box.

The guarantee matters more here. If your dog destroys a toy, the company replaces it. For a true power chewer, that policy alone can justify the higher price.

Head to head

Toy toughness: Super Chewer, by a wide margin. BarkBox toys are for play, not demolition.

Treat quality: Roughly even. Both use treats made in the USA and Canada with no artificial flavors, and both let you flag allergies.

Variety and fun: BarkBox. The monthly themes and creative designs are the whole point, and dogs that like novelty do well.

Price: BarkBox is cheaper by about $10 a month at time of writing.

Customization: Both are good. BarkBox edges ahead with options like the all-treats box.

What a box costs over a year

On annual plans, BarkBox runs a few hundred dollars a year before discounts, and Super Chewer runs about a hundred more. Longer plans cut the monthly rate, and both brands run sales around holidays.

Compare that to buying separately: two decent toys and two treat bags a month from a pet store easily tops $40. The box is not the ripoff it looks like at first glance. The catch is control. You get what they send, and if your dog hates a particular toy, you are relying on the replacement guarantee to make it right.

Who should skip the box

Dogs with severe food allergies do better on a tightly controlled diet chosen with a vet, not surprise treats. Dogs that swallow chunks of toys are a safety question, not a toy question: no toy is indestructible, and the guarantee replaces toys, it does not supervise your dog. And if your dog is toy-ambivalent, the money goes further toward training classes or treats they already like.

Verdict by dog type

Best for power chewers: Super Chewer. The reinforced toys and destruction guarantee are made for them.

Best for playful dogs who like variety: BarkBox. Fun themes, creative toys, lower price.

Best for dogs who ignore toys: BarkBox with the toy-free option, which doubles the treats instead.

Best for multi-dog homes: Either works, but Super Chewer's tougher toys survive being fought over.

One caution: no subscription box replaces training or exercise. A bored dog with new toys is still a bored dog. But as a monthly surprise, both boxes deliver. See current plans and themes at BarkBox.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

BarkBox. If you sign up through this link we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Check current price